Menu engineering matrix: find your Stars, Plowhorses, Puzzles and Dogs

Sort every dish into Stars, Plowhorses, Puzzles and Dogs from its price, food cost and sales.

Last updated

Currency and period

Use one period for every dish, such as last month. Prices before sales tax.

Your dishes

One row per dish in the same menu section (mains with mains). Food cost is what one portion costs you in ingredients; sold is how many you sold in the period.

  • $
    $
  • $
    $
  • $
    $
  • $
    $
  • $
    $
  • $
    $
  • $
    $
  • $
    $

Your menu matrix

Example numbers
Profit line (average margin)
$9.82
Popularity line
8.75% of sold
Sales
$21,050
Food cost
30.0%

Plowhorses · 3

Popular, below-average margin

  • Crispy chicken sandwich
  • Mac and cheese
  • Chicken Caesar salad

Stars · 2

Popular and above-average margin

  • Classic burger
  • Salmon bowl

Dogs · 1

Not popular, below-average margin

  • Veggie wrap

Puzzles · 2

Above-average margin, not popular

  • Steak frites
  • Fish tacos

Top row: popular. Right column: margin at or above the average.

DishMarginMixFood costClass
Classic burger$10.5028.0%30%Star
Crispy chicken sandwich$920.7%31%Plowhorse
Steak frites$156.0%40%Puzzle
Salmon bowl$139.3%32%Star
Chicken Caesar salad$910.7%25%Plowhorse
Mac and cheese$717.3%22%Plowhorse
Fish tacos$114.7%27%Puzzle
Veggie wrap$6.503.3%35%Dog

Stars: Keep them as they are. Give them the best spot on the menu, keep the recipe and portion consistent, and test a small price rise.

Plowhorses: Don't drop them; guests come for them. Lower the cost (portion, garnish, cheaper side), raise the price a little, or pair them with a high-margin side or drink.

Puzzles: Help them sell: a better spot on the menu, a clearer name and description, a photo, a staff recommendation, or suggest them with a popular dish. Check the price isn't the problem.

Dogs: Remove them, or rework the recipe and price. Keep one only if it has a reason, like a regular's favourite or a dish that makes a big order.

Margin here is price minus food cost (8 dishes, 1500 sold). Labor and packaging are not in it.

Put your Stars where customers order

Make a Menuthere ordering page with your menu and a QR code. You can mark top dishes, suggest a dish when another goes into the cart, and see every dish sold in Analytics.

Create your free ordering page

About this tool

Menu engineering sorts every dish by two numbers: how many you sell and how much each one leaves you after food cost. Type each dish's price, food cost per portion and the number sold last month. The matrix marks each one a Star, Plowhorse, Puzzle or Dog with the classic Kasavana and Smith rules, and says what to do about it.

How it works

  1. 01

    List one menu section

    Mains with mains, starters with starters. For each dish type the menu price, the food cost of one portion and how many you sold in the period.

  2. 02

    Read the matrix

    Each dish is compared with two lines: the average margin per dish sold, and 70% of an equal share of sales. That puts it in one of four boxes.

  3. 03

    Act and re-check

    Copy the result or download it as a CSV. Change prices, placement or recipes, then run the next month's numbers.

How the matrix decides

  • Contribution margin = menu price − food cost of one portion. A $14.50 burger that costs $4.60 leaves $9.90.
  • Menu mix = the dish's portions sold ÷ all portions sold in the section.
  • Profit line = the average margin per dish sold: total margin of the section ÷ all portions sold. A dish at or above it has a high margin.
  • Popularity line = (100% ÷ number of dishes) × 70%. With 8 dishes that is 8.75%. A dish at or above it is popular.
  • Stars are popular with a high margin, Plowhorses popular with a low margin, Puzzles high margin but not popular, Dogs neither.

The rules are the ones Michael Kasavana and Donald Smith published at Michigan State University in 1982. They judge a dish by the money it leaves, not by its food cost percentage. For the full method, read the menu engineering guide.

Worked example: 8 mains, one month

These are the tool's example numbers, not a benchmark. The restaurant sold 1,500 mains for $20,930, leaving $14,467 after food cost. The profit line is $14,467 ÷ 1,500 = $9.64 a dish, and the popularity line is 100% ÷ 8 × 70% = 8.75% of mains sold.

Example month, mains only
DishPriceFood costSoldMarginMenu mixClass
Classic burger$14.50$4.60420$9.9028.0%Star
Salmon bowl$19.00$6.10140$12.909.3%Star
Crispy chicken sandwich$13.00$3.90310$9.1020.7%Plowhorse
Chicken Caesar salad$12.00$3.20160$8.8010.7%Plowhorse
Mac and cheese$9.00$2.10260$6.9017.3%Plowhorse
Steak frites$26.00$10.4090$15.606.0%Puzzle
Fish tacos$15.00$4.2070$10.804.7%Puzzle
Veggie wrap$10.00$3.6050$6.403.3%Dog
  • Steak frites has the worst food cost, 40%, and the best margin, $15.60. A food-cost-only review would cut it; the matrix says sell more of it.
  • Mac and cheese has the best food cost, 23%, but leaves only $6.90. It sells well, so it stays, but it is the first dish to pair with a drink or a side.
  • The veggie wrap is the only Dog. Rework it, or keep it only if it brings in a group that orders other dishes.

Questions, answered.

A two-by-two grid that sorts the dishes in one menu section by popularity and by contribution margin (price minus food cost). The four boxes are Stars, Plowhorses, Puzzles and Dogs. The method was published by Michael Kasavana and Donald Smith at Michigan State University in 1982.

Each dish's share of portions sold is compared with 70% of an equal share. With 8 dishes an equal share is 12.5%, so the line is 8.75%. A dish that sells 8.75% or more of the section is popular.

Because you bank money, not percentages. A $26 steak at a 40% food cost leaves $15.60; a $9 pasta at 23% leaves $6.90. Food cost percentage would favour the pasta. Track both, but rank dishes by margin.

From your POS item sales report for the period. On Menuthere, Analytics lists every dish sold with its quantity for any date range, on every plan. Use the same period for every dish.

No. Compare dishes that compete for the same choice: mains with mains, starters with starters, drinks with drinks. Mixing them makes cheap, high-volume items look like Stars.

After any price, recipe or supplier change, and at least every few months. Seasonal menus need their own period. Keep each month's CSV so you can see whether a Puzzle moved after you changed its place on the menu.

Put your Stars where customers order

Make your own ordering page with a QR code. Mark top dishes, suggest a side when a main goes into the cart, and see every dish sold.